diff --git a/workflow/engine/classes/Cases.php b/workflow/engine/classes/Cases.php
index a75f61c87..982b32868 100644
--- a/workflow/engine/classes/Cases.php
+++ b/workflow/engine/classes/Cases.php
@@ -5714,7 +5714,7 @@ class Cases
                     '',
                     '',
                     'pending',
-                    '',
+                    1,
                     $dataLastEmail['msgError'],
                     true,
                     isset($arrayData['APP_NUMBER']) ? $arrayData['APP_NUMBER'] : 0,
diff --git a/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppMessage.php b/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppMessage.php
index 90f1fc9a4..8758937b3 100644
--- a/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppMessage.php
+++ b/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppMessage.php
@@ -160,7 +160,7 @@ class AppMessage extends BaseAppMessage
      * @param string $appMsgTemplate,
      * @param string $appMsgAttach,
      * @param string $appMsgStatus,
-     * @param string $appMsgShowMsg,
+     * @param integer $appMsgShowMsg,
      * @param string $appMsgError,
      * @param boolean $contentTypeIsHtml
      * @param integer $appNumber,
@@ -183,7 +183,7 @@ class AppMessage extends BaseAppMessage
         $appMsgTemplate = '',
         $appMsgAttach = '',
         $appMsgStatus = 'pending',
-        $appMsgShowMsg = '',
+        $appMsgShowMsg = 1,
         $appMsgError = '',
         $contentTypeIsHtml = true,
         $appNumber = 0,
diff --git a/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppNotes.php b/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppNotes.php
index 3885aa6ad..a36b13681 100644
--- a/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppNotes.php
+++ b/workflow/engine/classes/model/AppNotes.php
@@ -238,7 +238,7 @@ class AppNotes extends BaseAppNotes
                     '',
                     '',
                     'pending',
-                    '',
+                    1,
                     $msgError,
                     true,
                     (isset($fieldCase['APP_NUMBER'])) ? $fieldCase['APP_NUMBER'] : 0,
diff --git a/workflow/engine/src/ProcessMaker/BusinessModel/ActionsByEmail.php b/workflow/engine/src/ProcessMaker/BusinessModel/ActionsByEmail.php
index d5d4f087b..bdd47c37d 100644
--- a/workflow/engine/src/ProcessMaker/BusinessModel/ActionsByEmail.php
+++ b/workflow/engine/src/ProcessMaker/BusinessModel/ActionsByEmail.php
@@ -411,7 +411,7 @@ class ActionsByEmail
                     '',
                     '',
                     'pending',
-                    '',
+                    1,
                     '',
                     false,
                     isset($dataRes['APP_NUMBER']) ? $dataRes['APP_NUMBER'] : 0,